Introduction
Russia's actions in Ukraine have both current relevance and a historical precedent. During the Cold War, the Soviet Union became the dominant power in the Black Sea. However, after the collapse of the empire, Russia lost most of its territory in the region, with former Soviet states slowly inching closer and closer to the West.
This historical context is crucial to understanding the current tensions between Russia and Ukraine.
Russian aggression on its border with Ukraine has triggered one of the greatest security crises in Europe since the Cold War. In 2014, Russia seized Crimea, an important port region in Ukraine.
Conflicts between the two militaries continue to this day, but the recent Russian build-up of 100,000 troops along the border has escalated tensions to unprecedented levels. Moscow has denied that it is planning a military intervention but has presented NATO with a list of security demands.
Geopolitical Significance
Russia views the Black Sea as central to its security due to its abundance of warm water ports, including Sevastopol in Crimea. Catherine the Great annexed Crimea from the Ottoman Turks in 1783.
Russia’s desperation for a warm water port is not unfounded; most of its other ports freeze for several months each year. By seizing Crimea, Russia gained access to its only true warm water port in Sevastopol. However, access out of the Black Sea into the Mediterranean is still restricted by the Montreux Convention of 1936, controlled by Turkey.
During the Cold War, the Soviet Union became the dominant power in the Black Sea. However, after the collapse of the empire, Russia lost most of its territory in the region, with former Soviet states slowly inching closer and closer to the West.
Russia had an agreement with Ukraine that allowed them to divide the Black Sea Fleet, which remained docked in Sevastopol.
In 2010, Kyiv renewed Moscow’s lease on the fleet until 2042, but after pro-Russian president Viktor Yanukovych fled Ukraine in 2014, Putin feared Ukraine might renege on the agreement.
NATO and Russia’s Demands
Russia has demanded that NATO:
Ban Ukraine and other former Soviet states from joining NATO.
Abandon military activity in Eastern Europe, which would mean pulling out combat units from Poland and the Baltic states.
NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg has stated that Russia has “no right” to interfere. These demands highlight the ongoing geopolitical struggle between Russia and the West.
Ethnic and Political Dynamics
There is a significant Russian population in Ukraine, with over 500,000 people holding Russian passports. According to the most recent census, there are around eight million Russians living in Ukraine, mostly in the South and East.
Putin has used the presence of ethnic Russians as a justification for supporting separatists in southeastern Ukraine, describing the area as Novorossiya or New Russia. Putin’s imperialistic foreign policy is extremely popular at home, with interventions in Ukraine pushing his approval ratings to 80%.
Energy Dependency
Russia holds significant sway over Europe due to its natural gas supplies. Russian gas supplies account for 43% of the total gas imports into the EU.
Around one-third of Russian gas to the EU travels through Ukraine, making European nations particularly sensitive to conflicts between the two.
During past disputes, Russia has turned off its gas pipelines through Ukraine, causing significant disruptions in Europe.
Western Response
NATO and European countries have condemned Russia’s aggressive posture but have taken a relatively soft stance to avoid direct conflict. Economic sanctions imposed by the West after Russia's Crimea invasion did not have the desired effect.
Russia’s largest trading partner, China, complicates the West’s efforts to distance Russia from the global economy. Sanctions imposed after the Crimea invasion resulted in a 1 to 1.5% dip in Russia's GDP.
Implications for Global Order
The situation has highlighted the end of a unipolar world and the renewal of great power competition.
The US is strengthening its combat deterrent against Russia and enabling NATO forces to operate more effectively. The Department of Defence (DOD) has lifted the 25,000-man cap on active-duty troops in Germany and permanently based 500 US Army personnel in Germany.
Recent US withdrawals from the Middle East signal that Americans are wary of another protracted and costly conflict.
A Russian invasion of Ukraine could bolster NATO against a common enemy but also has negative ramifications for the US due to Russia’s trade relations with China and Europe’s energy dependence on Moscow.
Conclusion
Given that NATO is unlikely to acquiesce to Russia’s current demands, the situation seems to be at a stalemate. War would be devastating for all countries, while peace seems like a pipe dream at the moment.
The best outcome for everyone involved is to maintain the status quo – uphold the right to Ukrainian independence while keeping it at arm’s length from the West.
Note: In this CAPF essay of Why Ukraine is Crucial to Russia, the world limit has been crossed to give you more information, you can take relevant portions as per your need. Further, we have given subheadings for your reference. When you write in the UPSC exam, you don't need to do that.
Importance for UPSC CAPF Aspirants.
This article is crucial for UPSC CAPF AC aspirants as it covers several relevant topics:
Geopolitical strategies and international relations.
The role of energy resources in global politics.
NATO’s strategic importance and Russia’s demands.
Historical context of the Cold War and its impact on current events.
Economic sanctions and their effectiveness.
Understanding these dynamics is essential for answering questions related to international security, energy dependency, and geopolitical strategies in the UPSC CAPF AC exam, as well as for essay writing and current affairs preparation. This topic also intersects with subjects like history, economics, and political science, making it a multidisciplinary study area for comprehensive exam preparation.
Relevant Keywords: Russia-Ukraine conflict, Russian energy dominance, NATO and Russia, Ukraine crisis, geopolitical strategies, energy dependency, international relations, Cold War, sanctions on Russia.
Comments