Introduction
The emergence of cryptocurrencies has the potential to significantly impact geopolitics and change the nature of money.
Visionaries like Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg argue that digital currencies are better suited for a multipolar world as they are free from the control of any individual nation.
The two biggest competing powers, the United States and China, are not trying to democratize the monetary system but rather cement their influence over it.
Understanding Cryptocurrencies
According to Tim Massad, a former chairman of the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission, a cryptocurrency is defined by three key elements:
Digital Representation of Value: It is a digital representation of value.
Electronic Transferability: It can be transferred electronically.
Digital Ledger Recording: It is recorded in a widely accessible digital ledger.
There are two primary types of digital currency: state-issued and private entity-issued.
Sovereign Digital Currencies (CBDCs)
Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs), like China’s Digital Yuan, are government-issued and validated by the central bank of the issuing country.
Aaryaman Vir, a crypto entrepreneur, notes that CBDCs have little to do with true cryptocurrencies as they lack the core element of decentralization.
They are similar to existing fiat currencies but operate on newer technology platforms.
Private-Sector Digital Currencies
Private-sector digital currencies generally rely on decentralized blockchain technology. Examples include Bitcoin and Ether.
These currencies fluctuate in value relative to traditional fiat currencies like the US dollar.
A subset of cryptocurrencies, known as stablecoins (e.g., Facebook’s Diem), are pegged to a fiat currency and designed to remain relatively stable in value.
Advantages of Cryptocurrencies
For consumers, cryptocurrencies offer several benefits:
Lower Transaction Costs: Transaction costs are much lower than fees levied by traditional banks.
Enhanced Security: Cryptocurrency transactions are more secure because the transaction values cannot be replicated. This reduces the risk of fraud.
Speed and Efficiency: Cryptocurrencies enable faster and more efficient transactions across borders.
For governments, CBDCs can be advantageous if they exploit first-mover advantages.
China, for instance, is far ahead in developing its sovereign digital currency and setting up exchanges with other countries.
Countries that introduce favorable regulations for cryptocurrencies, like Portugal, can attract significant capital inflows.
Transforming Financial Systems
Cryptocurrencies have the potential to transform the entire financial system. Balaji Srinivasan, the founder of Coinbase, argues that central bankers have largely quashed price discovery, making it difficult to gauge the health of individual companies or the economy as a whole.
With digital wallets, individuals could hold a wide range of assets, from cryptocurrencies to CBDCs to fiat currencies, every stock, and even non-traditional assets like a minute of one’s time or a gigabyte on a hard drive.
In practice, if digital currencies were widely adopted, it would create a decentralized finance matrix where every asset competes against every other asset globally, ensuring complete price discovery.
This change is ushering a new era of global monetary competition, where national currencies must earn their place in someone’s digital wallet every hour of every day, even among their own citizens.
Ending American Financial Hegemony
The US Dollar is the dominant reserve currency and is the benchmark for global trade. This dominance allows the US to manipulate its currency at will, often with global ramifications.
For instance, when the US left the Iran nuclear deal, it threatened to exclude companies violating US sanctions from the SWIFT banking system, a network controlled by a few large banks.
Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg argue that digital currencies can democratize the financial system and reduce reliance on any single nation’s currency.
China’s Digital Ambitions
China aims to replace the Dollar with the Yuan or Digital Yuan. According to a Carnegie India report, China’s strategy to challenge the Dollar’s hegemony involves moving away from the Dollar and creating new payment systems like CBDCs.
China’s One Belt One Road (OBOR) initiative, often viewed through the lens of physical infrastructure, is equally about building digital infrastructure to support a future international payment system. The Digital Yuan is already in use by over 220 million users in China.
The Chinese Central Bank has explored cross-border digital currency payment projects with Thailand, the UAE, and Hong Kong.
Developing Nations’ Perspective
Developing countries seek independence from the Dollar or Yuan as global reserve currencies.
Cryptocurrencies are seen as neutral, not controlled by any single nation, and can provide financial independence.
For instance, El Salvador recently adopted Bitcoin as legal tender to attract capital and transform its economy into an international crypto tax haven.
Cryptocurrencies could also free nations from US and International Monetary Fund (IMF) interventionist policies.
In 2019, the IMF’s intervention in Ecuador’s economic crisis involved severe spending cuts, leading to increased unemployment and poverty.
Concerns and Risks
While embracing cryptocurrency offers benefits, poorly designed structures could destabilize financial systems. Cryptocurrencies could weaken governments' ability to set monetary policy.
For instance, widespread adoption of a cryptocurrency like Bitcoin could take important monetary decisions out of the hands of central bankers. Additionally, cryptocurrencies pose significant security risks.
They could be used for terrorist financing, drug trafficking, ransomware attacks, and money laundering due to the lack of regulation surrounding exchanges. There is also the risk of sanction evasion.
Countries like Iran could bypass Western sanctions using cryptocurrencies. According to blockchain analytics firm Elliptic, Iran’s bitcoin mining generates significant revenues that help mitigate the impact of US sanctions.
Geopolitical Implications
Cryptocurrencies can empower relief efforts, as seen with Ukraine accepting millions in crypto donations during the crisis.
The rise of cryptocurrencies could lead to a new digital reality where individuals, companies, and governments that adapt quickly will benefit the most and shape this new financial landscape.
Conclusion
Cryptocurrencies hold the potential to transform geopolitics and the nature of money, posing both opportunities and risks.
While they can democratize the financial system and reduce reliance on dominant currencies like the US Dollar, they also present challenges in terms of security and monetary policy control.
The future of cryptocurrencies will largely depend on how well systems are designed, regulated, and adopted globally.
Note: In this CAPF essay on Cryptocurrencies vs. Traditional Currencies, the world limit has been crossed to give you more information, you can take relevant portions as per your need. Further, we have given subheadings for your reference. When you write in the UPSC exam, you don't need to do that.
Relevance to UPSC and Other Competitive Exams
This article on Cryptocurrencies vs Traditional Currencies is significant for UPSC CSE, UPSC CAPF, Assistant Commandant, Essay Writing, Current Affairs, NDA, CDS, SSB Interview, AFCAT, IAS, IB ACIO, and Current News.
Understanding the potential impact of cryptocurrencies on geopolitics and the nature of money provides insights into economic strategies, international relations, and global financial systems.
This knowledge is crucial for competitive exam preparation, offering valuable content for essays, interviews, and current affairs discussions.
Comments